Equity Funds vs Index Funds: Know the Difference

Investing in mutual funds is one of the ways to grow wealth over long term and build a financial future. Within mutual funds, equity funds vs index funds are two of the most common types. Both of these funds invest in stocks, but they differ in terms of strategy, cost structure, and risk. Understanding the difference between equity and index fund can help you make an informed decision about which investment type aligns best with your financial goals.

What Are Equity Funds?

Equity funds are a type of mutual fund that primarily invests in the stocks of publicly traded companies. They pool money from many investors and use that capital to build a diversified portfolio of equities (stocks) with the goal of achieving returns from price appreciation and dividends. The primary focus is on the securities market, which allows investors to benefit from long-term capital gains, dividends, and the overall growth of the economy.

There are several different types of equity funds available to investors, each with a distinct investment strategy:

• Large-Cap Funds: These funds invests in well-established companies. They are typically considered comparatively safer investments vis-à-vis smaller companies, as they tend to be more stable. They tend to offer slower but a positive growth. These funds are considered comparatively low-risk, offering steady returns over time.
• Mid-Cap and Small-Cap Funds: These funds focus on medium-sized and small-sized companies. They generally tend to be more volatile than large cap funds.
• Growth Funds: Growth equity funds focus on companies that have the potential for high earnings growth. These companies might reinvest profits to expand rather than paying dividends. Growth funds are typically more volatile, but they may offer the possibility of higher returns. These funds are suitable for investors who have a higher risk tolerance and are looking for aggressive growth.
• Value Funds: Value funds seek to buy stocks that are undervalued relative to their intrinsic value. These funds aim to profit as the market eventually recognizes the true value of these stocks and their prices rise. Investors in value funds are generally looking for companies with robust fundamentals but temporarily lower stock prices.

A key advantage of equity funds vs index funds is that equity funds provide diversification by holding a variety of stocks, reducing the risk of individual stock ownership. However, the performance of actively managed equity funds depends heavily on the ability of the fund manager to select and allocate the right stocks. The skill and judgment of the fund manager can significantly influence the returns you receive.

What Are Index Funds?

Index funds are another type of mutual fund designed to replicate the performance of a specific underlying market index. Rather than relying on fund managers to actively select stocks, index funds are designed to passively track a specific market index, such as the Nifty 50, Nifty Midcap 100 etc. However, even passive funds require fund managers to ensure efficient replication of the index, manage tracking errors, and handle rebalancing when index compositions change. The goal of an index fund is not to outperform the market but to replicate the performance of the index it tracks. Investors in index funds generally expect to match the performance of the broader market rather than trying to beat it.

Key characteristics of index vs equity funds include:

1. Passive Management: Index funds do not engage in frequent trading or stock selection. They simply replicate the index’s composition by investing in the same stocks in the same proportion. This approach leads to relatively lower management costs and expenses. The absence of active management also means that index funds generally have lower turnover, which results in fewer taxable events.

2. Diversification: Since index funds invest in a broad range of stocks that make up the market index, they provide instant diversification. This broad diversification can help mitigate risks that may arise from any single stock or sector.

3. Lower Fees: The passive nature of index funds means they have lower management fees compared to actively managed equity funds. Since the fund doesn’t require analysts to research and select stocks, operating costs are minimal. This makes index funds a cost-effective investment option for investors looking to keep fees low.

4. Transparency: Because the composition of an index fund is tied to the underlying index, investors have full visibility into what they are investing in. The fund’s holdings are publicly available, and the fund’s strategy is straightforward, making it easier for investors to understand. This transparency is one of the key benefits of index funds vs. equity funds, as there is less ambiguity surrounding where your money is invested.

5. Market Bound Performance: While index funds don’t offer the potential for high returns like actively managed equity funds, they aim to track the market and offer long-term growth. Index funds tend to grow in line with the overall market, providing a comparatively stable growth trajectory for conservative investors.

Equity Funds vs Index Fund: Key Differences

Aspect	Equity Funds	Index Funds
Investment Style	Can be actively or passively managed.	Passively managed, tracking a specific market index.
Benefits	Potential for higher returns through stock picking. Professional management by experts. Flexibility in targeting specific sectors.	Low management fees. Broad market exposure and steady growth. Flexibility in targeting specific sectors.
Drawbacks	Higher management fees. Performance is largely dependent on the fund manager’s skill.	Performance tied directly to the market index. Lack of control over stock selection.
Performance Goals	Aimed at outperforming the market by selecting undervalued or high-growth stocks.	Aimed at matching the performance of a market index.
Risk and Volatility	Higher risk and volatility, especially with actively managed funds.	Lower volatility, as the fund tracks a broad market index.
Diversification	Offers diversification based on the fund manager's selection, but may vary.	Provides automatic diversification by tracking an entire index.
How to Choose	If you're willing to pay higher fees for the potential to outperform the market. If you believe in the skill of fund managers.	If you prefer low costs, simplicity, and broad market exposure. If you’re looking for steady long-term growth with minimal effort.

 

FAQs

1. How liquid are index funds compared to equity funds?

Both index funds and actively managed equity funds are quite liquid, but there are some differences in how they function. Index funds, being passively managed, generally have good liquidity since they track well-known market indices. You can buy or sell units easily, but transactions happen at the end-of-day NAV, and the settlement usually takes a day or two. Actively managed equity funds also offer liquidity, with redemption timelines similar to index funds. However, the liquidity of the stocks they hold may impact how efficiently redemptions are processed.

2. What are typical expense ratios for index funds compared to equity funds?

One of the major difference between index and equity fund is their expense ratios. Index funds generally have lower expense ratios compared to equity funds. Because they are passively managed and simply track an index, index funds have fewer operating costs. 

In contrast, equity funds, particularly actively managed ones, often have higher expense ratios due to the costs associated with stock selection, research, and fund management. The higher fees for equity funds are meant to cover the costs of professional managers and the resources required for active stock selection.

3. How do I choose between an equity fund and an index fund?

Choosing between equity funds and index funds depends largely on your financial goals, risk tolerance, and investment philosophy:

Risk Tolerance: If you are comfortable with higher risk and are willing to pay higher fees for the chance of outperforming the market, an equity fund may be more appropriate. If you prefer lower-risk investments and don't mind market-average returns, index funds may be a better fit.

Investment Horizon: For long-term investors looking for a more hands-off approach, index funds tend to be a great option, as they provide broad market exposure and lower fees. If you’re looking to take a more active role in managing your portfolio and have the time to monitor your investments, equity funds might be worth exploring.

Cost Sensitivity: If keeping investment costs low is a priority, index funds are generally the more cost-effective choice due to their lower fees.

4. What are the risks associated with investing in equity funds and index funds?

Typically, since both the underlying securities in both the fund types are stocks, hence risks associated between equity funds vs index funds largely remains high. An additional risk that Equity Funds carry is its dependence on fund manager’s ability to generate alpha. Index Funds on the other hand don’t possess the fund manager’s risk as it only replicated the underlying index.

5. What are the tax implications to consider when investing in index funds versus equity funds?

Index Funds: Short-term capital gains (STCG) are taxed if sold within a year, and long-term capital gains (LTCG) are taxed if held longer than one year.

Equity Funds: STCG are taxed if sold within a year, and LTCG are taxed after one year, subject to an exemption limit.

6. Which is better, an equity fund or an index fund?

Investments in equity funds vs index funds is a matter of choice based on several factors. It largely depends on your investment goals Equity funds offer the potential for higher returns but come with higher costs and risks, while index funds are a more cost-effective, passive option with broad diversification and steady long-term growth.

 

Disclaimers

Investors may consult their Financial Advisors and/or Tax advisors before making any investment decision.

These materials are not intended for distribution to or use by any person in any jurisdiction where such distribution would be contrary to local law or regulation.  The distribution of this document in certain jurisdictions may be restricted or totally prohibited and accordingly, persons who come into possession of this document are required to inform themselves about, and to observe, any such restrictions.

MUTUAL FUND INVESTMENTS ARE SUBJECT TO MARKET RISKS, READ ALL SCHEME RELATED DOCUMENTS CAREFULLY.